Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: General Sabotai
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Mongolian Chat > Mongolian Serious Talk
Bulldogg
Ghenghis Khan this & Ghengis Khan that, no disrespect to the man who started it all.

But brilliant General Sabotai, who was a General for Genghis’s son Ogotai (or Ogedei), should have never ever turned back. History later on would often ponder on what would have become & what would have been? If General Sabotai did not turn back his invasions & pushed forward into the heart of Europe?

Could we have seen a more different world these days? in culture, ethnicity?

I believe yes.

Heil, General Sabotai. The silent leader behind the Great Khan's family dynasty.
bowdown.gif
Subedey
wow you guys love me here. hmmm...actually, the name is Subedey. embarassedlaugh.gif
Jt (mongolian)
QUOTE (Subedey @ Mar 12 2006, 12:57 PM) *
wow you guys love me here. hmmm...actually, the name is Subedey. embarassedlaugh.gif

you consider you'relf is in subedey that's weird
lovelytruth
Zaluusaa (orchin tsagiin) Mongoliin tuhai yamar negen gegeeleg zuil baiwal bicheerei.
Ene muusain hujaa nar Mongoliin orchin tsagiin gaigui yum baiwal...albaar hed hedeeree orj irj eldew heruul margaan uusgej sedwees ni hazailgachihaad garaad yawchihdag nohoi sanaatai hulgaichid daa.
Humuust bidniig ertnii humuus (hotsrogdson) gej oilguulah tiim yum ih hiih durtai garuud.
Ongorson tuuh ene terteigee zuuraldaj hotsorson oodgui amitad gej boduulah geed l....

Za demiireed hardaad baina geed bas bitgii dairaad baigaarai...aliwaa yumiig hemjeend ni oilgoh ch bas zugeer hog shuu.
Bidnii tuuhiig delhii medne dee.Gehdee bitgii tiim yum hel bich gesen ug bish shuuu.
Harin orchin tsagiin Mongoliin tuhai gegeeleg sanaa onoo,zuil baina uu geh geed baina.Tegwel bicheerei ok amjilt gej
JiG
Did you know Subotai was said to be so fat that he had to be carted around in a wagon? When I read this in a book it changed my whole perspective of him. Regardless though, he was a genius military leader and posterboy of the Mongol meritocracy.
Bitterlemon
QUOTE(JiG @ Apr 29 2006, 03:34 AM) [snapback]1799702[/snapback]

Did you know Subotai was said to be so fat that he had to be carted around in a wagon? When I read this in a book it changed my whole perspective of him. Regardless though, he was a genius military leader and posterboy of the Mongol meritocracy.


No, that's not true embarassedlaugh.gif . Subedey wasn't that fat. I read that Chinggis Khaan once presented Subedey one of his favourite horses and Subedey rode that horse in the next battle. So if he was that fat obviously he can't ride a horse.
JiG
Oh, I think I got mixed up with some other mongol leader. I read it in "Genghis Khan: and the making of the Modern World - Jack Weatherford".
Anda
Subeday Ba'atar (c1176-1248) 15-04-2004


In most accounts of the Mongol conquests Genghis Khan's subordinates come over as two-dimensional characters, mounted automatons moving as stereotypically as the myth of Mongol supremacy would always have us believe. Yet in the service of Genghis Khan were many leaders of great military talent who were personalities in their own right. One of them was Subadai Ba'adur, whose name variously appears as Subedei, Sabatai, or Subodei. He was born in about 1176 the son of a blacksmith of the Uriangqadai clan and joined Temuchin's band when he was still a youth in about 1190. Along with his brother, ]elemei, Subadai rose quickly in Mongol service and commanded cavalry at the age of 25. Subadai appears to have been a heavyweight in more ways than one, and had to travel to battles in some form of carriage to spare the backs of the slight Mongol ponies!

Subadai is the exemplar of that remarkable and commendable loyalty shown by subordinate generals of the Mongols towards their ruling Khan. ' As felt protects from the wind,' he promised to Genghis Khan, 'so I will ward off your enemies.' His first independent command was in 1205-06 when he successfully pursued and killed Kutu and Chila'un, sons of the defeated Merki leader, Tokhto'a. Subadai commanded a tumen (10,000 men) in the wars against the Xixia, and we read of him being given joint command of the 3,000 Mongols sent in pursuit of the Shah of Khwarazm after the Samarkand operation. When the Shah died in 1221, Subadai was one of the commanders entrusted with the reconnaissance mission 'to the Western lands' that took the Mongols into Russia for the first time.

This operation was a remarkable feat that brings great credit upon Subadai. Having destroyed several towns in Azerbaijan, the Mongols were bribed to spare Tabriz, and he and his men wintered in eastern Armenia. In 1221 the two generals defeated King Giorgi the Brilliant of Georgia near Tbilisi. From there they returned to Azerbaijan and were on the point of marching against Baghdad to destroy the Abbasid Caliphate, but instead returned to Georgia, defeating another Georgian army using the tactic of false retreat. They then swung north and advanced into southern Russia and captured Astrakhan. Pushing on across the river Don they penetrated the Crimean peninsula and were in the Ukraine to winter the snows of 1222-23. In 1223 they began to return home, only to be intercepted by an allied enemy force. These were the soldiers Subadai and his colleagues led to their deaths at the battle of the Kalka river.

Their earlier conquest of the territory of the Shah of Khwarazm had taken the Mongols as far as the borders of Azerbaijan, at which point Subadai and Jebe asked permission to proceed north and reconnoitre the 'Western lands'. This led to the conquest of Azerbaijan and Georgia, after which they came upon the nomadic Polovtsians, referred to in the chronicles as Kipchaks or Cumans (Kumans). By 1223 the Mongols had completed these operations and regrouped in the southern Russian steppes.
At that time what we now know as Russia and the Ukraine were ruled by a number of princes who jealously defended their own territories. These Russian princes would appear to have had no intelligence about the campaigns and conquests of Genghis Khan, and the first information that a new enemy had appeared in the southern steppes was brought to Mstislav Mstislavitch in Galich his Polovtsian father-in-law, Khan Kotyan, whose nomadic territory lay close to the eastern most bend of the Dnieper. The Chronicle of. Novgorod tells us:

He brought them numerous presents: horses, came/s, buffaloes and girls. And he presented these gifts to them, and said the following, 'Today the Tartars took away our land and tomorrow they will come and take away yours.'

The name Tartars or Tatars is the expression often used in Russian source materials for the Mongol hordes. The original Tartars were a rival tribe wiped out by Genghis Khan, but the expression may also derive from Tartarus meaning 'Hell', the supposed origin of these strange warriors who had appeared from nowhere.

Map copied from: "Genghis Khan & the Mongol COncuests 1190-1400" from Stephen Turnbull by Osprey Publishing, see Sources.


Mstislav of Galich immediately summoned a council of war in Kiev. The two other southern regional princes attended it: Mstislav Romanovich of Kiev and Mstislav Svyatoslavich of Chernigov. They made the decision that the Russians and Polovtsians should move east to seek out and destroy the Mongols wherever they might be found. When the expeditionary force was on its way the Mongol envoys met the main body at Pereyaslavl and tried to persuade them from fighting. But when a second attempt at parley failed the army crossed the Dnieper and marched eastwards across the steppes for nine days, little knowing that they had been misled by a Mongol false retreat conducted on a grand scale. Here they encountered a Mongol army at the Kalka river and were heavily defeated:

...his Kuman warriors failed, and retreated in such haste that they galloped over the Russian camp and trampled it underfoot. And there was not time for the Russian forces to form ranks. And so it came to complete confusion, and a terrible slaughter resulted.

Mstislav of Kiev defended himself inside a hastily erected stockade until he was persuaded to give himself up by Ploskyn, a Cossack leader fighting for the Mongols who swore 'on the holy cross' that Prince Mstislav would be released for ransom, but:

...this accursed Ploskyn lied, and he bound the princes hand and feet and turned them over to the Tartars. The princes were taken by the Tartars and crushed beneath platfoms placed over their bodies on top of which the Tartars celebrated their victory banquet.

Following the death of ]ebe on the return journey, Subadai successfully led the Mongol army home having covered around 6,500 km (4,000 miles) in less than three years.
Subadai may have served in Genghis Khan's last campaign against the Xixia, but the next action for which he is renowned was the successful siege of the ]in's southern capital of Kaifeng in 1232, where Subadai had to contend with thunder crash bombs thrown by catapult. That was the last Subadai was to see of campaigning in China, although in 1257 his son, Uriyangkhadai, led an army into the country now known as Vietnam, and his grandson, Bayan, was to accomplish the destruction of the Southern Song in 1276.


Subadai's last and greatest campaign was the invasion of Russia and eastern Europe, described in detail above. Batu, son of Jochi, was the overall leader, but Subadai was the actual commander in the field, and as such was present in both the northern and southern campaigns against Russia and the Ukraine. He commanded the central column that moved against Hungary. While Kaidu's northern force won the battle of Leignitz and Kadan's army triumphed in Transylvania, Subadai was waiting for them on the Hungarian plain. The newly reunited army then withdrew to the Sajo river where they inflicted the tremendous defeat on King Bela IV at the battle of Mohi. Subadai masterminded the operation, and it was to prove one of his greatest victories.
The king had summoned a council of war at Gran, an important settlement on the south of the Danube bend upstream from Buda and Pest. As Batu was advancing on Hungary from the north-east it was decided to concentrate at Pest and then head north- east to confront the Mongol army. When news of the Hungarians' apparent intentions reached the Mongol commanders they slowly withdrew, drawing their enemies on. The Mongols took a stand near Eger to the east of the river Sajo, on a flat plain bounded to the north by the famous wine-growing area of Tokay. It was a strong position. Woodland prevented their ranks from being reconnoitred, while across the river on the plain of Mohi, the Hungarian army appeared to be very exposed.
Subadai launched the battle of Mohi during the night of 10-11 Apri11241, only one day after his compatriots had won the great battle of Leignitz. One division crossed the river in secret to advance on the Hungarian camp from the south-east. The main body began to cross the Sajo by the bridge at Mohi. This met with some resistance, so catapults were used to clear the opposite bank. When the crossing was completed the other contingent attacked at the same time. The result was panic, and to ensure that the Hungarians did not fight desperately to the last man the Mongols left an obvious gap in their encirclement. As they had planned, the fleeing Hungarians poured through this opened trap which led to a swampy area. When the Hungarian knights split up, the light Mongol archers picked them off at will and it was later noted that corpses littered the countryside for the space of a two days' journey. Two archbishops and three bishops were killed at the Sajo. By late 1241 Subadai was discussing plans to invade Austria, Italy and Germany, when the news came of the death of Ogodei Khan, and the Mongols withdrew.
With his return to Mongolia Subadai's name disappears from history. Perhaps he retired from active service, because we know he was dead by 1248. He remains one of Genghis Khan's most celebrated generals, and there is a statue of him in Ulan Bator, honouring a fine soldier and a loyal and honourable follower of the Mongol Khans.

JiG
I knew it i was right!!!!
Bitterlemon
QUOTE(JiG @ Apr 30 2006, 08:48 PM) [snapback]1805122[/snapback]

I knew it i was right!!!!


Was that horse so huge & strong? Or it happened before Subedey gained weight?? confused.gif
JiG
I'm thinking it was before he could enjoy the fruits of his labour.
batu
He was actually the greatest mongolian general imo. zev comes second. muhulai third
Subotai
me too fat icon_redface.gif
Son of A Sun
haha
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.