Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: News: HANOI, Vietnam -- A Vietnamese court convicted a journalist and
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Vietnamese Chat
HelloEveryone

Just to show you the kind of coward tactics that the Police used to oppress our common Vietnamese people, who don't have a voice:

Copyright 2010. The Associated Press All Rights Reserved
HANOI, Vietnam -- A Vietnamese court convicted a journalist and democracy activist of assault and sentenced her to three-and-a-half years in prison Friday in a one-day trial that rights groups said was meant to silence government critics.

Tran Khai Thanh Thuy, 49, was found guilty by the Hanoi court of assaulting two people outside her home last October. Her husband, Do Ba Tan, 50, received a two-year suspended sentence on the same charge.

Thuy is one of Vietnam's small circle of dissidents who have promoted political pluralism, which is not tolerated by the Communist government. She is the 17th democracy activist jailed here in just over three months.

Human rights groups say undercover police recruited thugs to attack Thuy - and then charged her with assault.

"Let me out of here, I can't stand this trial anymore," Thuy cried out as the prosecutor read the charges against her. Her outburst prompted a brief pause in the proceedings.

Prosecutors said that Thuy and Tan assaulted two people on the evening of October 8, after one of them complained that Tan's motorbike was blocking the alley outside the couple's home in Hanoi.

Tan bashed one of the victims in the face with his motorbike helmet and Thuy threw bricks at them and beat them with a stick, prosecutors said.

They said one of the bricks injured Nguyen Manh Diep, who had asked Tan to move the motorbike.

Thuy testified she acted to defend her husband after she came outside and saw him being beaten. She said she threw a brick to scare the attackers away, but it did not hit anyone.

Then, Thuy said, someone picked up the brick and hit her on the head with it.

"I'm the victim here, not a criminal," Thuy said.

When neighbors tried to help her, Thuy said, local security forces prevented them from doing so.

But after a one-day trial, the court ruled against Thuy and her husband, saying she had been the main aggressor in the incident.

"The defendants' hooligan-like actions belittled the law and harmed the health of others," said judge Tran Thi Phuong Hien.

As the verdict was read, Thuy protested again and the judge ordered police to remove her from the court.

Foreign reporters were not allowed to enter the courtroom but watched the proceedings on a closed-circuit television elsewhere in the building. They were not allowed to bring cameras.

U.S.-based Human Rights Watch says the couple were roughed up by thugs who were waging ongoing harassment of Thuy. Earlier that day, the group said, police had prevented Thuy from attending the trial of democracy activists in the northern city of Haiphong.

"Charging the victim of a beating with assault is yet another example of Vietnam's Kafkaesque efforts to silence government critics," Brad Adams, Asia director for Human Rights Watch, said in a statement.

Thuy has been active in the dissident community since 2006, when she started organizations to help workers and assist farmers whose land had been confiscated by the government. Thuy, who worked for many years in Vietnam's state-controlled media, later wrote for an online pro-democracy newspaper and published a blog.

Since then, thugs have thrown excrement and dead rodents at her gate and locked her out of her house, according to Human Rights Watch, and police subjected her to a "People's Court" at which 300 people gathered in a public stadium to insult her.

She was also placed under house arrest and held in a detention center for nine months, the organization said.

In recent weeks, Vietnam has sent 16 democracy activists to jail. Some were convicted of spreading propaganda against the state, and others were convicted of attempting to overthrow the government by joining pro-democracy parties.

Western diplomats have decried the campaign against dissent, which they say is the result of political jockeying among factions in advance of next year's Party Congress, during which the country's new leaders will be chosen.

Earlier this week, in a speech marking the Communist party's 80th birthday, party chief Nong Duc Manh said Vietnam was "determined to fight the plots of hostile forces who are ... calling for a multiparty system and abusing democracy and human rights issues to sabotage our socialist regime."
vietnam
Ok, what's going on here...Why can't I find my last post about the cadre-as-judge combo system in VN???? Did that thread actually get deleted? embarassedlaugh.gif



Aristotle
I notice that the Vietnamese constitution, the laws, they're very decent and just. The only problem is that the government do not follow their own laws therefore the structure of society is unjust. When martin Luther King challenged the U.S structure he argued that the U.S constitution stated: " all men are created equal and that they endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, and among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." MLK was trying to make the U.S follow their own laws and deliver to the Negroes :" life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness," that the U.S constitution guaranteed to all men.

The move the Vietnamese government pulled is a characteristic of an totalitarian move, they modify and adjust law to support the power structure. In the short run they might continue to stay in power with this move, however, in the long-run people will start to notice that these people don't even follow their own law and they will not be taken seriously. Furthermore, a lot of people will be pissed.
vietnam
You got it right. The Constitution of VN is very good on the paper, comparable and sometimes identical to the Declaration of Independence of the USA. It's the interpretations of the Constitutional words that marks the difference between the two camps.

Aristotle
The Vietnamese constitution is good but it is missing check and balances.

Don't moan, organize...A lot of instances the U.S do not follow their own laws but the government was put in check by its citizens.

There is not enough gun, bullet, or prison cell to hold everyone. There is a hell lot more of YOU than them. Spread the words, unify, organize and then confront the problem and make them follow their own laws. The revolution is not yet completed, but the only beginning. When the government do not follow their own laws then they're nothing but a bunch of thugs.The Vietnamese people need to take their god dammed country back.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.